Skip to content

Pattern Review: EvaDress Patterns 1929 Evening Frock

2013 May 20
by elizabeth_admin

Saturday night was the night of the Gatsby Gala and I did indeed finish and wear my Gatsby dress.  It was a very interesting evening.  Very interesting indeed.  The dresses were all very beautiful.  Most were beaded affairs.  Others chose the fringe dress route.  There was definitely a sexy 20’s vibe going on.  I think I was one of a few of women who chose the  20’s dropped waist look.  Here’s my review.

6634

 

Pattern Description:  1929 Evening Frock and Vest.  I made only the frock.

Pattern Sizing:  Size 18.  I made it up with an FBA of 1.5 inch increase.  As I mentioned earlier, Sherril, Jeannette and Kellie helped me with fitting the bodice at PR Weekend in San Francisco.  We added some fisheye darts in the front and back to make the bodice more fitted and flattering.  The unfitted style of the bodice and dropped waist combined with my bust line and hips were doing me no favors.  However, in the end, I decided to forgo the extra shaping despite my vanity as it took the dress out of the 20’s era.

Did it look like the photo/drawing on the pattern envelope once you were done sewing with it?  Kinda sorta.  I think the pattern drawing is of someone who is 8 ft tall and 9 inches wide.  So on me it looks somewhat wider and shorter than the svelte drawing you see above.  I guess ladies in the 20’s had to deal with idealistic pattern drawings as well.  😉

Were the instructions easy to follow?  Yes.  They were a little old fashioned, but pretty concise and very clear.  I followed them for the most part, except for topstitching the skirt onto the bodice.  I emailed Beth from SunnyGal Studio last week hoping she would share some of her expertise with me.  She had some great tips for order of construction and how to attach the skirt to the bodice, particularly the vee insert at the front.  Her advice and lots of practice on scraps were how I was able to make it through the torture of working with silk charmeuse the construction of this dress.  One note though about the pattern instructions, they mention piecing the skirt pattern pieces depending on how wide your fabric is.  Beth advised to place the front and back pieces on top of each other to match the side seams and then mark a point for the piecing join so it is the same on both sides. 

IMG_5252

 

IMG_5250

 

What did you particularly like or dislike about the pattern?  I loved how perfect it was for my event.  I loved the vee insert design detail (until I had to actually sew it of course).  No real dislikes actually aside from the lack of shaping (ahh vanity, you are so cruel a mistress).

IMG_5247

 

Fabric used:   Silk charmeuse in the most gorgeous shade of emerald green.  I was hoping for my own Atonement moment.  Haha.  The lining is a silver china silk.  Both fabrics I bought from Mood Fabrics.  I bought the silk charmeuse in person at the NYC store, but the lining from their on-line store.  Originally I was going to use some raspberry colored china silk for the lining, but thought it was too garish in the end and ordered the silver at the last minute.  I was anxiously tapping my foot waiting for the UPS man to deliver it last Wednesday.  My silver sequin trim is from Pacific Trimming.  Both fabrics were wonderful to work with if a bit recalcitrant.

Pattern changes or design changes made:  The main change I made was including an FBA on the bodice.  After constructing the dress and trying it on, I took a photo of it to send to Beth, Sherril, Jeanette and Kellie.  Beth suggested pleating the straps since they were a bit too wide and matronly.  I also took in the side seams a bit and put in some shaping at the CB.  These changes necessitated a zipper; I put it in at the side seam.  Of course, as luck would have it, I had to insert that stupid zipper in three times.  Three times.  Into silk charmeuse.  I wouldn’t wish that on my worst frenemy.  Oh, ok, maybe I would.  The last change I made was to construct the lining as one piece (meaning bodice and skirt in one but with a front and back).  This meant free hand drafting the skirt portion off of the bodice pattern piece.  I flared it out at the waist and made sure not to exceed the width of the skirt.

pleated shoulder strap

pleated shoulder strap

 

an invisible invisible side zipper

an invisible invisible side zipper

 

Any problems encountered during construction?   I think the toughest problem I encountered during the construction of this dress was overcoming my vanity issues.  Sigh.  Then there was the silk charmeuse.  Oy vey, this fabric is a bitch.  A gorgeous bitch though.  It was like working with liquid gems it was so lustrous.  But oh it was so shifty and wouldn’t hold its shape.  I had to stay the neckline with silk organza.  I constructed the bodice separately from the skirt to save having the skirt pattern pieces lying around and losing their shape from handling, whims of the gods, etc.  The vee waist seem was highly tricky.  I kept making samples, but each one was successively becoming crappier, so I had to just go for it on the real deal.  Was there swearing?  Yes.  Was there screaming?  Yes.  Did I finally manage it?  Yes.  Was it enjoyable?  NO!  Is it behind me?  Yes thank the gods.  Did I mention the THREE zipper insertions???

Any new techniques learned?  Well let’s see, the vee waist seam with the inset corners.  Sherril sent me this on-line tutorial on inset corners from Threads.  It’s fantastic.  Bookmark it!

Any interesting design details in this pattern?  Did I mention the vee waist seam?  It’s the make it or break it detail of the dress.  And the wrong trim could just sink it.  I love my trim.

Which sewing machine(s) did you use for construction?   Since I was working with silk charmeuse again, I chose the Emerald 183 again.  However, I opted not to use the walking foot and weirdly didn’t have any slippage issues.  Weird.

Time to complete construction:  Not including the muslin and the pointless dithering over the shapelessness of the dress’ silhouette, about 4 and half intense days.

Will you sew it again or recommend it to others?     I most likely will not make it again as I don’t foresee going to any more Gatsby galas in the near or far future.  But I definitely do recommend it to anyone who has their own Gatsby gala coming up.  I would advise making a muslin first for sure though, preferably in a like fabric.  Making my muslin up in actual muslin was quite demoralizing.  Definitely consider reshaping the straps/armhole to be more appealing.  And don’t forget that the trim makes this dress, so choose carefully. 

Conclusion:  One of the most impactful things Beth told me in our conversations about this project was that this was a costume.  At first my immediate reaction was it’s not a costume, but she was right.  It took a lot of pressure off of me.  Where and when the heck am I going to wear this dress again?  Probably nowhere and never.   It’s a costume.  And after all the angst and trials in making the dress, it ending up being a great dress.  Nuff said.

 

And now without further ado, here’s how the dress looked on me.

IMG_5238

 

at the gala

at the gala

 

And my beautiful parents.

IMG_5217

 

And because my project list is long with a lots of deadlines, I spent my entire day working on Jack’s costume for his acting debut as Scottie Pup #2 in the school play, 101 Dalmations.  Here he is in a partially constructed Scottish tam.   I had not yet added the pompom or his scotty ears when I snapped this picture.  But isn’t he just the cutest???  I know I’m the mom here, but come on!

IMG_5254

 

Happy sewing!

24 Responses leave one →
  1. May 20, 2013

    Oh, that vanity of yours should be very happy: You look absolutely lovely in that frock! And that colour looks stunning on you.

  2. May 20, 2013

    What fun! A gorgeous dress. I hope you get to wear it again

  3. May 20, 2013

    What an achievement! You look beautiful. I can’t believe you put that zip in three times. My fabric would have been in shreds. And of course your boy is cute. He’s grown so much! Definitely not the baby I met!!!

  4. May 20, 2013

    You look gorgeous in your dress, emerald is a beautiful color on you. Your parents look fabulous, too. Jack is such a cutie in his hat.

  5. Ceci permalink
    May 20, 2013

    You look wonderful in the “at the event” picture…….especially in a dress designed for an 8 foot tall beanpole! and of course the Scotty Tam shot is adorable. Perhaps he will wear the hat without the ears beyond the play? Its so handsome….

    Ceci

  6. Laura permalink
    May 20, 2013

    The pattern may have been a bitch…..but you conquered it…..and looked fabulous in it. The green was PERFECT

  7. May 20, 2013

    This is so fabulous! You did a wonderful job on a difficult project!

  8. May 20, 2013

    What a fabulous dress! All of the torture/frustrations/angst of working with silk charmeuse was definitely worth it! Your little one is too cute!

  9. May 20, 2013

    The colour and the embellishment are stunning – you look gorgeous! And of course Jack looks super cute too 🙂

  10. Rosie permalink
    May 20, 2013

    Emerald green is definitely one of your colors! You look fantastic. Silk charmeuse can be a pain but you did a great job. Your parents and Jack look great.

  11. cindy permalink
    May 20, 2013

    I think you’re being way too hard on yourself. You look great! And so do your parents! I don’t think it looks unflattering at all.

  12. May 20, 2013

    Fantastic, you look beautiful and I agree with everyone, emerald green is your color. Your whole family looks fantastic. and for some reason that guy in the white suit over your shoulder made me think – Elton John is at her party 🙂

  13. May 20, 2013

    How beautiful!! That’s a spectacular dress and you wear it so nicely. And your baby really is growing up. 🙂

  14. May 20, 2013

    It looks awesome! Such a great color, and totally worth three zipper insertions.

  15. May 21, 2013

    Elizabeth you look fab in your dress – well done for overcoming the silky-sewing-challenges 🙂

  16. May 21, 2013

    It’s lovely, Elizabeth. Great job!

  17. May 21, 2013

    You look freaking fanTASTIC in that dress!!!!!! I love it!!!!! xoxos

  18. May 21, 2013

    You look great, the colour is so gorgeous. This is the year for Gatsby parties so I hope your dress gets another outing.

  19. elizabeth_admin permalink*
    May 22, 2013

    Thanks everyone! I ended up liking a dress I thought I would hate. It was fun to wear and unique. Loved the emerald green color too. I was the only wearing that color. 🙂

    Thank you again!

  20. Meredith permalink
    May 22, 2013

    I never saw the picture of Jack–cute!–when is the play?

  21. May 24, 2013

    Great job, Elizabeth! Love the color on you…

  22. May 27, 2013

    That is gorgeous! You did an amazing job. Very inspirational.

    (I just remembered that I promised myself I’d finally cut into silk fabric–which scares me–before the end of the school year. Time is running out!)

  23. Mary permalink
    September 9, 2013

    Nice fit. Beautiful dress! The green is gorgeous.

Trackbacks and Pingbacks

  1. It takes a village | SEWN

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

  • Follow SEWN...
  • My Weapons of Mass Construction

    Singer Featherweight 221 (1938)
    Baby Lock Imagine
    Brother 2340CV
    Husqvarna Viking Emerald 183
    RIP: Brother 1034D
  • Translation


  • I’m a proud member of




  • I support

    Project 95
  • Archives

  • Categories

  • The Trench Sew Along